3 Reviews for The Edgewater Grille

• September 7th, 2009 - 12:55 pm Review by Joe Baughn
  Overall Rating

  • 4 from 5

  Not only do they have the best hamburger in Indiana we are doubly treated by having our good friend Peggy Pinder wait on us. We have appreciated Peggy’s service for many years including her days at Pinder’s Restaurant, a dining experience we miss to this day.

  Add this to the fact that they have brought back Herb(I apologize that I do not recall his last name) to greet us and attend to our every request in his friendly way, and you have the perfect dining experience. We thank Dan for having the foresight to bring Herb back.

• July 19th, 2010 - 1:51 pm Review by Guest
  Overall Rating

  • 5 from 5

  Herb is a joke. If you don’t want to slip him $20 expect to wait a long time for a table. This is a small town, not Chicago.

• July 19th, 2010 - 1:52 pm Review by Guest

  My above rating is acually a 1*, solely because of the way Herb treated us.